What the exam asks
Two equations are given, one in x and one in y. You find the roots and compare: x > y, x < y, x ≥ y, x ≤ y, or x = y / relation cannot be established. Mains also uses quantity comparison (Quantity I vs Quantity II), where a quantity may come from arithmetic instead of an equation. Target: 30 to 40 seconds per question.
Finding roots fast (factorisation)
For ax² + bx + c = 0: find two numbers whose product = a x c and sum = b. Split the middle term, then the roots are those two numbers with signs reversed, divided by a.
Example: 2x² - 11x + 15 = 0. a x c = 30, need sum -11: -5 and -6. Roots = 5/2 and 6/2 = 2.5 and 3.
Sign rule (find signs without solving)
| Signs of b and c | Signs of roots |
|---|---|
| + , + | both negative |
| - , + | both positive |
| + , - | one positive, one negative (bigger one negative) |
| - , - | one positive, one negative (bigger one positive) |
Key formulas
- Roots = [-b ± sqrt(b² - 4ac)] / 2a
- Sum of roots = -b/a; product of roots = c/a
- D = b² - 4ac. D > 0: two real roots; D = 0: equal roots; D < 0: no real roots.
- x² = k gives x = +sqrt(k) and -sqrt(k) - two roots. x = sqrt(k) gives only the positive root.
How to compare
- Write both roots of x and both roots of y on a number line.
- If every x lies to the right of every y: x > y. If every x lies to the left: x < y.
- If they touch at one common value and otherwise x is right: x ≥ y (similarly x ≤ y).
- If the ranges overlap: relation cannot be established.
Worked example
I. x² - 13x + 42 = 0 and II. y² - 15y + 56 = 0
x: (x - 6)(x - 7) = 0, x = 6, 7. y: (y - 7)(y - 8) = 0, y = 7, 8. The value 7 is common and the remaining x is smaller, so x ≤ y.
Worked example 2 (quantity comparison)
Quantity I: x, where x² = 64. Quantity II: 8.
x = 8 or -8. So Quantity I ≤ Quantity II.
Common traps
- Forgetting the negative root of x² = k.
- Reversing signs incorrectly: if the factors are (x - 5)(x + 3), roots are 5 and -3.
- Comparing only one root of each equation - you must compare every pair.
- Equal roots: (x - 4)² = 0 gives only x = 4.